Jay and the Americans first hit the Billboard charts in 1962 with the tune “She Cried,” which reached #5. They returned to the charts in 1963 with “Only In America,” Other notable hits for Jay and the Americans were “Come a Little Bit Closer” in 1964, which hit #3, and “Cara Mia” in 1965, which hit #4. With the group’s third different “Jay” as lead singer, their show covers the group’s history, acknowledging all three Jays and featuring all of the top hits in their original arrangements.